
Jesus said to them, and still says to us:
Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven; for he makes his sun rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous.
Jesus, dwell deep within us and pour your great love into our hearts that we might do what you command: Love our enemies.
When I was growing up, and I would react negatively to something that another person was doing my father had a consistent response. “Bill, it takes all kinds to make a world.”
Indeed, it does! E Pluribus Unum. Out of many one.
So for the duration of this sermon, to make Jesus’ command to love our enemies real, and not an abstraction I’d like you to hold in mind someone or ones you regard as an enemy. It could be someone or some group on the other side of the political and cultural divides that plague our nation here as we celebrate 250 years of trying to become one nation out of many backgrounds. Or it could be a friend or colleague who betrayed your connection. Or a family member or former love from whom you have become separated. As you do this “reality check” about your enemies, I’ll be doing it right along with you. I’ll be holding in my mind and heart as I preach someone who years ago lured me into opening up a confidence, and then betrayed me.
When Jesus commands us to love our enemies – and in a minute I’ll say more about the word he uses when he says “love” – he’s not saying it because he wants us to adopt some politely social way of being “nice” to everyone, including people who have hurt us, or folks we don’t like or violently disagree with. He has a much higher goal in mind. He’s saying it because he wants us to become more and more like the God who sent him!
And to become more and more like the One who created us – and let us remind ourselves, the God who also created our enemies, the ones we fear, the ones we abhor and despise – then we must become ones driven by love, because God’s driving force is love. For as the First Letter of John states with utter clarity: “Whoever does not love does not know God, for God IS love.”
If God is love, then we must love, and when we do, we are becoming day by day with every loving act, more and more like the God who made us and commands us to love. The more we do this, the more perfect we become, as Jesus promises and commands when he says in his very last words to us in this morning’s Gospel; “Be perfect, therefore, as your Father in the heavens is perfect.” (Later in the sermon, I’ll have a bit to day about what Jesus means by being perfect. A hint: he’s not speaking about moral perfection.)
So, as I promised, let’s turn our minds and hearts to inquiring just what Jesus – and John’s letter – mean when they say that God is love and that we must love as God does. Love is such a slippery word in English – encompassing all sorts of feelings and actions. In his marvelous book The Four Loves, CS Lewis illuminates for us the various kinds of things that the English word love might mean. And his final goal in doing so is to open up for us the depths of what the NT means when it says that God is love, and that we must love, just as God does.
First some good news that will – I hope – help you to breathe a sigh of relief. [Fair warning: this is the prelude to some good news later in this sermon that may make you anything but comfortable.] Before he unfolds for us the kind of love that is divine love, Lewis talks about three other kinds of love that are not: philia (friendship), storge (familial and instinctual animal love), and eros (sexual) love. So to be clear, when Jesus commands us to love our enemies, he is NOT saying that we need to feel friendly towards or to like our enemies. Nor is he saying that we need to feel a kind of familial connection to our enemies. And he is certainly NOT saying that we need to be attracted in an erotic way to our enemies. WHEW! Well, all that’s a relief!
So if Jesus is NOT commanding us to treat our enemies as friends, or as family members, or as lovers, then just what kind of love is Jesus saying we should be bearing towards our enemies? Well, here is where the good news gets tough. (Don’t say I didn’t warn you!)
The word that Jesus uses when commanding us to love as God loves is – in the NT Greek – the word agape. Often people speak about this word as if it means unconditional love. But that definition has always sounded too abstract and distant to me, like an attitude more than an action.
So I think there is a better way to understand what agape means. Agape, the love of God and the kind of love to which God commands us, is the kind of love that pours out its energy in wanting and willing and working for what is best for the other. Acting for the good of the other. Pouring itself out, using its energy for the other’s good, even if the other is downright evil and isn’t a good guy, and doesn’t live by right action (that’s after all, what righteous means).
Did you notice the example that Jesus gave of how active God’s love is? Jesus said that God “makes his sun rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous.” Amazing right?! God’s love is profligate, not picky. Causing the goodness of sun and rain to be there for all of us, and for all of us all the time, whether we’ve been particularly good or downright evil. Does this play havoc with your picture of God? Maybe that’s exactly what Jesus had in mind. God is bigger than the way our minds conceive of God. God is not some moral scorekeeper in the skies, doling out good or bad towards us depending on how good or bad we’ve been. And thank God for that, because otherwise we’d all be doomed to many sunless days, and many weeks of drought.
Of course, this sort of love is hard for us to grasp fully, because it truly is divine love, beyond our normal human loves that seeks some good return for our loving actions. At the heart of this kind of love is God’s capacity, God’s very nature, to hold the good and the bad within God’s very heart, holding us all there equally, and not doling out good only when we are good. No, the Holy One – whose Name should be blessed forever – acts for the good for all of us all the time: even when we turn our backs on God, and when we turn our backs on one another and hurt one another.
This is what the Cross of Jesus means. When we look upon the Cross and see Jesus hanging there, arms outstretched, we are given a picture of how God is: arms outstretched to the whole world, ALL THE TIME, and outstretched not just to ones like his mother and his beloved disciple at the foot of the Cross, but to all the others there, to the soldiers who drove the nails into his flesh, to the soldiers who without an ounce of care or compassion gambled for his clothes, to the ones who jeered at him. In other words, to all of them, and all of us. Equally. Always.
Nearly incomprehensible, isn’t it? And isn’t that why we come here or to places like this week by week? To try to understand and experience that divine love more deeply – to let it sink into our hearts and minds and guts more deeply – just how wonderful and life-changing this kind of love is. And to pray for that same kind of love to overtake us, so that we might live out that kind of love, even if only a bit more, day by day, and week by week. That’s why the Prayer Book includes in daily Morning Prayer this wonderful prayer. [It’s on page 101, if you’d like to follow along and perhaps join me in praying it aloud right now. By doing so we’ll be fulfilling for a moment Jesus’ command to pray for our enemies.]
Lord Jesus Christ, you stretched out your arms of love on the hard wood of the cross that everyone might come within the reach of your saving embrace: So clothe us in your Spirit that we, reaching forth our hands in love, may bring those who do not know you to the knowledge and love of you; for the honor of your Name. Amen.
Amen indeed! As that word means whenever we pray it: so be it! Or as Captain Picard used to say on Star Trek: Make it so!
For us to begin grasping just how strange and wonderful, how nearly beyond telling, this kind of love, this agape is, I think we need an example from the real world in which we live: a world where love like this has its vital role in the rough and tumble of life, where things are not always nice, in a nation where we are anything but united, and sometimes feel and act with hatred towards one another, in this kind of world, where something more than easy human “niceness” is needed if we ourselves and the world are to be converted to love more like God loves.
And so an example from the history of our nation, within living memory of all or nearly all of us here today as we celebrate 250 years as a nation. It was a beautiful fall day in Lancaster County, PA, in October of 2006, so almost exactly 20 years ago. It was a school day, and local Amish schoolgirls made their way to their hamlet’s schoolhouse, where, as they did every morning, they listened to their teacher read from the Bible, and then they prayed in German the Lord’s Prayer – with its telling words “Forgive us our sins, as we forgive those who sin against us” – and then they sang some hymns in German.
About 10:15 a local milk truck driver, with a grudge against God for the death of his little daughter who had died on the day she was born, entered the schoolhouse, and ordered the little girls there to lie face down on the floor. He fired his semi-automatic pistol, killing five of them and grievously wounding five others, leaving them in critical condition. As police crashed through the schoolhouse door, he turned the gun on himself, and took his own life.
After burying their beloved girls in simple white dresses, the Amish of Nickel Mines, PA did something that startled the world, and may startle you and me. They forgave the killer, and reached out to his widow and children. Three Amish men visited the widow to express their sorrow for her loss, and then called on the killer’s father and for an hour held him in their arms as he wept. “Arms of love stretched out upon their cross.” When the murderer was buried, more than half the mourners present at the burial were Amish.
How is such forgiveness, such compassion, such agape possible? When one Amish man was asked by a television reporter how he could forgive, he simply said, “Through God’s help.” God’s agape poured out, enabling agape to keep flowing.
Cheap grace, some said. But not so. The Amish learned through the centuries how to live such agape, such gracious love, through their own suffering. The Amish way of life was founded in Europe in the late 1600s, and they were brutally persecuted by Protestants and Catholics alike, martyred in the 1000s. Their agape, their ability to forgive, was forged in years of persecution, and then years of being jeered at, or grossly misunderstood by some in this country to which they fled in the 1720s, because of our promise of a way of life that would allow them freedom to live their faith without fear of violent persecution.
In other words, the Amish and their forgiveness of the milkman murderer show us that agape is never something easy. It is always forged in the crucible of our own pain – pain that can give rise to the deep desire, the loving passion to ACT IN LOVE, to assuage others’ pain, and when possible to prevent or heal that pain, knowing as we do, how much we need agape, loving action, to aid us when we ourselves are suffering.
But – and now remember the killer of those little girls – agape in the face of life’s painful brokenness is always a choice. It is never automatic. Our pain can cause us to rage and cause pain to others, OR it can – with Christ’s help – cause agape to well up within us, and so overflow for the healing of others.
Exactly one year after the little girls were murdered, the Amish published a letter – an epistle of agape love if you will – to anyone who cared to read it. In it, were these words: “Forgiveness is a journey…you need help from your community of faith and from God – and sometimes even from counselors, to make and hold on to a decision not to become a hostage to hostility.” “Hostility [they said] destroys community.”
And so we – who desire as Christians and Americans – to NOT become hostages to hostility come to this Table, to receive help from the One who chose agape instead of becoming hostage to all the hostility and to the fear of his way of love that led to murder on that Cross. And here at this Table, we have a chance to reach out our hands to receive him, and take him into ourselves, so that his love, his agape, may fill us, and drive out from us any hostility that might take us hostage. Instead of becoming hostages to hostility, we have the chance – through his agape gift of himself – to become hostages to agape. This is the way we pray for our enemies, and begin acting in agape love towards those who persecute or harm us.
So in a few minutes we can choose to consume Christ’s agape love. And as we do, his Presence, his indwelling love within us, will allow us – if we choose – to become living bearers of that agape love towards others: those we easily love, as well as those whom we regard as enemies. And as we do this, that is how we become more perfect – the Greek word used here really means to become more whole, not more morally pure. For that is who our Father in the heavens is: One whose love is so whole that God’s divine love embraces every one of us, and very bit of all of us – yes, all of us – all our evil and all our good – in an everlasting embrace that turns it all into everlasting agape. That is what heaven is – that everlasting embrace of divine biagape, here and now and unto the ages of ages. Amen. Make it so, good Lord! Make it so!

